Sire Table Snapshot -And Why Black Type Needs an Overhaul

Tara Madgwick - Monday October 28

A few big prizemoney races can skew sire tables, but with so many big prizemoney races on offer at this time of year there is a lot happening in the sire tables and you need a lot more than one big winner to make an impact with some value sires doing some pretty special things.

General Sires

Click for all the sire tables.

Pride of Dubai might have sired Bella Nipotina to win the Everest, but he’s had five stakes-winners in total which is equal to Zoustar and exceeded only by Snitzel, but there is a big difference in the service fees for these three sires!

Pride of Dubai priced at $22,000, Zoustar at $275,000 and Snitzel at $247,500.

Broodmare Sires

Click for all the sire tables.

Fastnet Rock is the reigning champion broodmare sire and will be a short priced favourite to take the title again and had a red letter Saturday siring Via Sistina (IRE) to win the Cox Plate in history making style, while he is also sire of the dam of El Castello, who won the Group I ATC Spring Champion Stakes.

Second Season Sires

Click for all the sire tables.

Darley shuttler Too Darn Hot (GB) setting the pace by winners, stakes-winners and earnings, but will lose his place at the top of the list if Castelvecchio’s star son El Castello backs up to win the Group I VRC Victoria Derby this Saturday which is worth $2million.

Advertisement

Castelvecchio was looking like he was going to struggle for numbers  at the stallion parades in August having covered his smallest book of 86 mares in 2023 and at the end of last season he had the uninspiring  stats of 19 runners for two winners with stakes-placed maiden El Castello the best of them.

Castelvecchio has gone from not to hot!

Fast forward two months and a lot has changed for Castlevecchio, who stands at Arrowfield this spring at a fee of $22,000.

He’s jumped right out of the ground and his lifetime stats are now looking a lot more favourable with eight winners from 36 starters and three of those winners are stakes-winners headed by El Castello.

Castelvecchio is one of the stallions affected by the current Black Type ‘is it or isn’t it’ debacle with his stakes-winner Aeliana winning the Group III ATC Reginald Allen Handicap which is only being recognized as Listed by Arion.

On the other hand his new stakes-winner Double Market has been given the status of a G2 winner for her win at Moonee Valley in a race that was clearly nowhere close to the standard required for a race of that level. Click here to see the race. Just take a look at the past winners of a race that is clearly in decline!

No disrespect to these fillies and their owners, but if we are committed to actually taking a good hard look at Black Type racing in this country then a complete overhaul is required and we need to look at the racing world that we have, not what we had. The modern spring carnival has very little correlation to what was around at the start of this century.

There are new races that deserve to hold Black Type and far too many old rusted on races that need a realistic assessment.

Advertisment
More Reading...
Sires With Winners - Saturday November 15
Here is the full list of 110 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Asterix back on top in The Beauford
Former Gr.1 New Zealand Derby (2400m) winner Asterix returned to top form and scored his first Australian victory in the A$300,000 NZB The Beauford (2300m) at Newcastle on Saturday.
G1 CF Orr Stakes - Two of Them in 2025 - Not All Change is Bad!
Flemington is done and dusted for another year, but Melbourne’s Spring carnival rocks on and programming changes continue, with the relocation of the MRC's time honoured G1 CF Orr Stakes from its traditional February slot.
Invincible Filly Wins $1million G3 Thoroughbred Club Stakes
I Am Invincible was expected to have the winner in the $1million Group III MRC Thoroughbred Club Stakes (1200m) at Caulfield on Saturday with race favourite My Gladiola coming out of a second placing in the Group I VRC Coolmore Stud Stakes, but it was another daughter of the champion sire that got the cash.
Sires With Winners - Friday November 14
Here is the full list of 62 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Max Lees 2YO Classic Sale Mail
The $160,000 Max Lees Classic (900m) is a spring scamper for juveniles at the standalone Newcastle meeting on Saturday that invariably produces a good contest and with 12 runners that are all unraced the Sale Mail and trial form will be the guide.
Jimmysstar all class in Orr Stakes triumph
Brilliant New Zealand-bred gelding Jimmysstar lifted his Group One tally to three with another scintillating performance in Saturday’s A$1 million CF Orr Stakes (1400m) at Caulfield, in which progeny of Little Avondale Stud stallion Per Incanto finished first and third.
Star Sprinter Jokers Grin Plays Winning Hand
On a big, boisterous opening day of The Pinnacles carnival at a packed out Ascot racecourse, WA’s reigning Horse Of The Year Jokers Grin was definitely the headline act.
Karaka Graduate Romanoff Wins G1 NZ 2000 Guineas
The only thing certain as horses slogged their way to the winning post in Saturday’s Gr.1 Al Basti Equiworld Dubai New Zealand 2000 Guineas (1600m) was that Matamata trainer Pam Gerard would produce the quinella in the Riccarton classic.
First Stakes Victory For Better Then Ready’s Epic Proportions
With victories in NSW, Victoria and Queensland since July, Ciaron Maher’s Better Than Ready gelding Epic Proportions has produced some strong efforts in his last four starts in the sunshine state, but none more so than his effort of Saturday to win the Listed BRC Keith Noud Stakes (1200m) when leading throughout.