The Melbourne Cup Miracle

Media Release - Sunday November 3

This is the story of how a horse bought for $5,500 from an online auction will run in the Melbourne Cup at just his 11th race start.

Margaret Falconer’s focus will go from one end of the scale to the other on Tuesday as she switches between Ellerslie and Flemington.

The Cambridge trainer will be at Ellerslie hoping to win a maiden race with the five-year-old Drake Bay, who has been placed in six of his 11 starts.

Like every other racing fan, Falconer’s attention will then zero in on the Gr.1 Melbourne Cup (3200m), but she has more interest in it than most people, having played a significant part in the education of one of the leading hopes, the New Zealand-bred Surprise Baby.

Surprise Baby is by Melbourne Cup winner Shocking - image Grant CourtneyA five-year-old gelding by 2009 Melbourne Cup winner Shocking, Surprise Baby was bred by Rich Hill Thoroughbreds and burst into prominence for the famous Flemington race when guaranteeing a start with his win in the Gr.3 Bart Cummings (2520m) at Flemington last month.

Horsham trainer Paul Preusker has guided Surprise Baby from a successful debut over 1200m on his home track just over 12 months ago to be tackling the Melbourne Cup in just his 11th start with prize money of A$723,735 to his credit.

Surprise Baby has won five times and has already proven himself over two miles, having won the Gr.2 Adelaide Cup in March when defeating Top Of The Range, Mike Moroney’s talented stayer who won Wednesday’s Gr.3 Bendigo Cup (2400m).

Falconer is amazed by Surprise Baby’s incredible climb to the top to contest the holy grail of Australasian racing, remembering the wayward young horse sent to her two years ago by Rich Hill Studmaster John Thompson.

“I got him for one prep after he had been passed in at the Ready To Run Sale,” Falconer said.

Surprise Baby was passed in not once but twice,  as a yearling and again at the Ready to Run“He wasn’t easy to steer and when you look at his breeze-up for the Ready To Run Sale you can see why he wasn’t sold.

“He wasn’t an easy horse to handle when we got him. He was never dirty, he just needed to be taken along quietly.

“He didn’t have a good mouth and we ended up re-mouthing him and virtually going back to scratch with him.

“The boys spent a bit of time and we got him to the track, up doing half-pace. We never really galloped him, but he always had a good action.

“We probably had him for about three months and he had done enough and needed a break. The next I knew he had been sold.”

Advertisement

Surprise Baby had originally been passed in by Rich Hill Stud at the 2016 New Zealand Bloodstock Select Yearling Sale with a $20,000 reserve and he failed to meet a $35,000 reserve at the 2016 Ready To Run Sale when again offered by the Walton nursery.

“He didn’t breeze up well,” Thompson said. “I put him in work with Margaret Falconer with the idea of winning a trial and getting him sold.

“He proved a bit difficult and he never got to the trials early in his three-year-old season, so I thought we’d missed the boat.”

Rich Hill Stud principal John Thompson (left) with John Fiteni and Kathy Stewart, owners of Surprise Baby. That’s when Surprise Baby was listed on gavelhouse.com in November 2017 and bought by his Australian part-owner John Fiteni for a mere $5500. Fiteni then got Preusker to come to New Zealand to inspect him and the rest is history.

“I watched his first race and he was pretty erratic that day, too,” Falconer said.

“His trainer has done a great job with him and he has obviously had someone very good to ride him in work and keep him going forward.

“He was a nice, scopey type of horse and was always going to keep developing. He was just mentally immature and needed time.

“We gave him the break when we did because, if we’d kept going, we could have blown his brain.

“He’s obviously an amazingly tough horse. I never imagined he would be running in the Melbourne Cup this year.”

Falconer and her partner, Richie Whitworth, are kept busy with 15 horses in work, five of their own racehorses (headed by recent winner Red Sky At Night) and the remainder being pre-trained.

As well as training, Falconer is a breeder and shareholder in Shocking with a three-year-old filly, three two-year-olds fillies and a yearling colt all by the Rich Hill Stud-based sire waiting in the wings.

“It’ll be great for the New Zealand breeding industry and especially for Shocking if Surprise Baby can emulate him and win the Melbourne Cup,” she said. - NZ Racing Desk

Visit the profile page for Shocking

Shocking in upcoming sales:
Advertisment
More Reading...
Karaka 2026 – The Sire and Vendor Break Up
Flying the G1 flag for Kiwi-breds in Australia this spring have been Ceolwulf, Jimmysstar, Mr Brightside, Globe and of course the world’s best sprinter Ka Ying Rising, so we’re busting to take a look at the sire and vendor break up for the 2026 Karaka Books 1 and 2.
Sires With Winners - Tuesday November 18
Here is the full list of 25 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Pedigree Watch – 3YOs for Autumn
We know about the three year-olds that found G1 success this spring, but there were a couple that came to the party late and hold G1 promise for the autumn, so who are they?
One to Watch – Kyneton
Annabel and Rob Archibald send out runners all up and down the Eastern States and a Written Tycoon filly that bolted in at Kyneton on Tuesday delivered a timely update for her half-sister headed to Magic Millions in January.
One to Watch – Scone
Astute trainer Brad Widdup was a visitor to the Perth Magic Millions Yearling Sale in 2024 and he signed for four yearlings with the most expensive being a filly by Western Austalia’s champion sire Playing God and she made a winning debut at Scone on Tuesday.
Juvenile Trial Watch – Rosehill
Three heats for juveniles over 900m were run at Rosehill on Tuesday morning and the winners included the highest priced yearling by Exceedance in 2025 and a filly by first season sire Tiger of Malay.
Options Open for Star Kiwi 3YOs
With a quinella in Saturday’s Gr. 1 Al Basti Equiworld Dubai New Zealand 2000 Guineas (1600m) done and dusted, trainer Pam Gerard is now setting about confirming summer plans for Romanoff and Affirmative Action.
Caulfield 2YO Sale Mail Today
The Caulfield meeting on Wednesday features a juvenile contest with seven runners that include a pair of youngsters from the powerful Lindsay Park training team and a well bred filly from the Grahame Begg stable.
Sires With Winners - Monday November 17
Here is the full list of 9 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Strong Trade Goffs November Foal Sale Day 1
Strong trade in today's opening session of Goffs November Foal Sale resulted in increases in all key indicators of market health with the top two lots sired by Starman, while a colt by Ghaiyyath also made a splash.