'Write Off' Rules Excludes Your Foals

Media Release - Monday September 23

When our office takes over new breeding industry clients one of the biggest problems, we find, is how poorly the special mare and stallion "write-off" rules have been applied.

Amongst the most common problems we find is the wrong application of these rules to horses bred by the breeder, i.e. "home-breds". I'm especially focusing on this problem due to the sheer volume of issues we've had with the wrong application of these rules to "home-breds" in the past 12 months.

Clarifying this aspect of these rules is well worth it as they are of enormous benefit to the tax position of breeders as they allow the accelerated write-off of eligible mare and stallion breeding stock and it is important to understand what eligible breeding stock they can be applied to.

What breeding stock do the "write-off" rules apply to?

The trading stock provisions of the Tax Act provide a different method for calculating the closing stock value of male and female horse breeding stock. Commonly referred to as the "write-off" provisions, broadly speaking under this method:

•A male horse breeding stock can be written down at a maximum rate of 25% on a prime cost basis to a minimum value of $1; and

•A female horse breeding stock can be written down at a maximum rate of 33 1/3 % on a prime cost basis so that the value is not less than $1 by the end of the year in which the horse is age 12. It follows that a mare acquired at age 12 or more can be written-off to $1 at the end of that tax year.

Although the closing value options for horse breeding stock is generally its cost, market selling value or replacement value, an additional special closing value option (i.e. the "write-off" rules) are available for a horse that is held for breeding , at least 3 years old and that was acquired by the taxpayer under a contract . It is this latter criterion that is so frequently misunderstood and applied, thus I expand on this criterion below.

A horse acquired "under a contract" does not include natural increase

For the purposes of the "write-off" rules a horse is "acquired under a contract" when it is acquired either by sale from an auction house or privately (say via an agent, "on-line" or directly with the seller). Note this does not mean a horse acquired by "gift" or from another party for no consideration. Remember, under contract law you cannot have a "contract" unless one of the parties gives "consideration".

By definition, the above excludes the acquiring of a horse by natural increase. This view is further supported by taxation ruling TR 2008/2, the current breeding and racing industry ruling.

Now…I've heard arguments that because you must enter into a "contract" with a stud farm or stallion owner to acquire a foal that such foals do meet the "contract" criteria. This is not accepted by the ATO, as noted in TR 2008/2 above. It appears a horse has to be "born" to be acquired under a contact. It's contentious, I agree, but that's the current ATO position, supported by many other leading tax authorities.

Let me provide an example below to clarify the points I have made above.

Example 1 – Horse acquired a contract

Carmela Pty Ltd is an existing breeding business and during the 2020 tax year introduced three broodmares to its breeding herd, being:

1. Tessa Bear – acquired for $55,000 (inc. GST) at a leading broodmare auction;

2. Samantha I Am – this mare was given to the company for NIL via a dear friend of the company owner who is quitting the commercial breeding game; and

3. Patricia – this mare was bred by the company and was first raced successfully by the company before being retired for breeding. The service fee incurred to acquire this mare was $27,500 (inc. GST)

Can Carmela Pty Ltd use the "write-off" rules in relation to these new mares?

· Tessa Bear – acquired via auction, she can be written-off under the write-off rules;

· Samantha I Am – acquired via a "gift" for no consideration, thus cannot be written-down under the "write-off" rules. Note – under special trading stock rules for disposals "outside the ordinary course of business", this mare would be acquired by the company for its market value, notwithstanding no monies changed hands; and

· Patricia – bred by the company, thus acquired via natural increase. This mare cannot be written-off under the "write-off" rules.

Advertisement

Is there a legitimate way you can use the "write-off" rules for your foals?

If your breeding business restructures its affairs, yes there is.

Either at commencement or during the life of a breeding business, you may decide, for perfectly legitimate commercial reasons and within the realms of Tax Law, to create a different entity to run the activities of your business.

When the horses are transferred to the new tax entity, say a trust or company, this constitutes the new entity acquiring the stock "under a contract". Thus, any horses transferred across that were originally bred by the owner can now utilise the "write-off" rules in the new entity. Refer example below.

Example 2 – A "home-bred" foal acquired by a new trading entity via a "contract"

Referring to example 1 above, Patricia and all of the mares and breeding stock of Carmela Pty Ltd are transferred to a newly set-up trust, the "Carmela Horse Trust", on 1 July 2020 to run the breeding business.

Patricia is now acquired via a "contract" by the new trust, thus she can be written down under the "write-off" rules within the new trust.

Please contact me if you wish for me to clarify or expand on any of the matters raised in this article.

Paul Carrazzo CA

Carrazzo Consulting Pty Ltd

801 Glenferrie Road, Hawthorn, VIC, 3122

TEL: (03) 9982 1000

FAX: (03) 9329 8355

MOB: 0417 549 347

E-mail: paul.carrazzo@carrazzo.com.au

Web Site: www.carrazzo.com.au


Advertisment
More Reading...
Sires With Winners - Wednesday May 28
Here is the full list of 44 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Juvenile Trial Watch - Rosehill
Trials this morning at Rosehill were run on a heavy 9 so horses were well held together and not asked for too much, but there were still a couple of intriguing unraced heat winners by Extreme Choice and Justify (USA), plus we got another look at the $1.4million Wootton Bassett (GB) colt from Sunlight.
Blue Gum Farm Announce 2025 Fees
Leading Victorian stud, Blue Gum Farm, is pleased to announce its 2025 stallion roster and service fees, headlined by exciting young sire Sejardan, who will stand at an unchanged fee of $13,750.
Sires Pack Profitable Punch at Weanling Sale
There are many members of New Zealand’s stallion ranks whose progenies racetrack results far exceed their service fee.  Next month’s NZB National Weanling Sale at Karaka is an ideal opportunity for traders and end users to secure the progeny of these creditable sires.
US Group I Winner for Zoustar
On a day when Widden Stud’s Zoustar produced the $5.25million top seller Zougotcha at the Magic Millions National Broodmare Sale he also sired a new Group I winner in North America where King of Gosford won the $300,000 Shoemaker Mile (1m) at Santa Anita.
Verry Exciting Weekend Looms
New Zealand horseman Nicholas Bishara will cross the Tasman this weekend to watch his filly Belle Detelle, a three-quarter sister to his ill-fated 11-time Group One Verry Elleegant, contest the Gr.1 Queensland Derby (2400m).
Newhaven Park Confirm 2025 Fees
One week after Newhaven Park bred, raised and sold Cool Archie recorded his second successive juvenile stakes race victory in the Group 2 Spirit of Boom Classic at Doomben, Newhaven Park stud principal John Kelly has confirmed the 2025 service fees for the first-crop 2-year-old’s sire Cool Aza Beel (NZ), as well as the farm’s two associate stallions Xtravagant (NZ) and Mo’Unga&nb
Expensive Ghaiyyath Colt Wins Stakes
Darley shuttler Ghaiyyath (IRE) had his first Australian winner earlier this week and overnight produced a new stakes-winner in the UK where Godolphin owned colt Opera Ballo won the Listed Heron Stakes (1m)at Sandown.
Breeding To Win - 2025 G1 Queensland Derby
It’s been 15 years since Dariana thumped the colts to win the Queensland Derby (2400m) in 2010 and maybe it’s time for another filly to triumph!
Little Avondale’s Weanlings Follow Successful Footsteps
Graduates of Little Avondale Stud’s drafts at the NZB National Weanling Sale have a proud record of racetrack success, and stud principal Sam Williams believes his class of 2025 compares favourably with previous years.