European form expert raises doubts over Caulfield Cup favourite

Ben Dorries - Friday October 20

A leading European form expert believes Caulfield Cup favourite Johannes Vermeer is silly odds given he feels there are serious doubts about the Irish raider running a strong 2400m.

Advertisement
Sky Racing's European form expert Richard Wade has a few question marks on whether Caulfield Cup favourite Johannes Vermeer will run a strong 2400m

Sky Racing's Richard Wade points out the Aidan O'Brien galloper has only once run over 2400m and feels he was clearly outstayed by stablemate Spanish Steps in the Group III Ballyroan Stakes (1m4f - 2414m) in Ireland in August.

Johannes Vermeer is as short as $4 in some Caulfield Cup betting markets after tumbling into favouritism following the injury during the week to Japanese galloper Admire Deus.

Many punters were taken with Johannes Vermeer's fast-finishing second on his Australian debut in the Group I Ladbrokes Stakes (2000m) last Saturday.

But European expert Wade, who originally hails from Yorkshire, isn't so sure.

"I think 2400m would be the absolute maximum he wants, at his second last run he was basically just outstayed by Spanish Steps," Wade said.

"The change of tactics with Johannes Vermeer to be ridden more forward will probably suit him in the Caulfield Cup.

"He could win but I struggle to see it, I think he is more of a 2000m horse and others will be stronger at the finish of the Caulfield Cup.

"I certainly think he is too short in betting."

Wade also ran his eyes over overseas-trained Caulfield Cup hopes Marmelo ($17) and Wicklow Brave ($51).

And he has discounted them both in the $3m race on Saturday.

The Hughie Morrison-trained Marmelo won the Group II Prix Kergorlay (3000m) in August, a race which is traditionally a good Melbourne Cup guide.

Protectionist won the Prix Kergorlay before claiming the Melbourne Cup in 2014 while Americain defeated Manighar in the 2010 edition of the French feature before winning the Melbourne Cup two starts later.

However Wade wasn't taken by the Kergorlay this year.

"It was a bit of a farce of a race this year when Marmelo got to the front and absolutely walked," Wade said.

"He is certainly still improving but I just can't see him winning over this short (Caulfield Cup 2400m).

"I am sure he is much more of a Melbourne Cup horse."

As for Willie Mullins' Irish stayer Wicklow Brave trying to become the first nine-year-old to win the Caulfield Cup, Wade can't see it happening.

But he does think Wicklow Brave's form hasn't deteriorated since he ventured to Australia last year as one of the top handful of Melbourne Cup hopes.

Wicklow Brave, who reverted to hurdle racing for his last win in April, was beaten more than 24 lengths in last year's Melbourne Cup after getting a torrid run from the widest gate.

"To be honest Wicklow Brave's form coming here this year is just as good, if not slightly better in patches, than it was last year," Wade said.

"I just think the Caulfield Cup distance will be too short for him.

"One thing about these dual purpose horses though, is they are tough horses."

Advertisment
More Reading...
Positive Build Up to Karaka Weanling Sale
Stars of the future go under the hammer at Karaka on Thursday with New Zealand Bloodstock’s National Weanling Sale set to commence at 10am.
Storm Boy Retired to Coolmore Australia
An utterly dominant winner of the $3 million Magic Millions 2YO Classic, the hugely exciting son of the international sire sensation Justify is set to join the Coolmore Australia roster in 2025.
Sires With Winners - Wednesday June 25
Here is the full list of 42 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Raging Force Bolts in at Randwick
Cosmic Force 2YO Raging Force was sent around in the Group III ATC Breeder’s Plate on debut last spring finishing sixth to King Kirk and coming out of the race with an injury, but time and a patient approach has put his career back on track.
Capitalist 2YO Wins for Doyle
Nathan Doyle and his team would be bubbling with excitement surrounding the return of their unbeaten G1 star Private Harry, but as they say ‘little fish are sweet’ and the stable were in the winner’s circle at Wyong on Tuesday with a two year-old son of Capitalist.
Irish Oaks Possible for Royal Ascot Fairytale Filly
The biggest story in terms of our audience reads from Royal Ascot last week was by far and away the one on the Aussie owned underdog three year-old filly Cercene, who captured the Group I Coronation Stakes.
Nice 2YO Winner for Vinery Value Sire
He might be the least expensive sire on the Vinery roster this spring at a fee of just $6,600, but Headwater gets his share of winners and produced a new two year-old winner at Doomben on Wednesday.
Hong Kong Buyer Secures Top Lot June (Late) Sale at $500,000
The impact of the recent success in Hong Kong of horses sourced on Inglis Digital was in evidence today, with the top lot and the third top lot bought by Hong Kong-based owners.
Tassort Filly Too Classy at Randwick
Stakes-placed two starts back in the Listed Woodlands Stud Stakes at Scone, talented 2YO Tassort filly Wollzeile proved too classy at Randwick on Wednesday.
One To Watch – Randwick
After impressing on debut, the Chris Waller trained 3yo Super Seth filly Frosty Girl (NZ) took on the older mares on the Kensington track, remaining unbeaten with another stylish victory to become Breednet’s One To Watch.