Godolphin Land Tax Ruling Setback

Media Release - Tuesday June 20

Back in April last year I wrote, with unbridled joy, about the Land Tax victory Godolphin had with Revenue NSW.

The “victory” involved Godolphin successfully arguing on appeal to the NSW Supreme Court that, for the purposes of securing land tax exemption, the dominant use of two of its properties in the Hunter Valley was for the maintenance of animals for the purpose of selling their bodily produce or natural increase, notwithstanding the racing related activities that occurred on the properties.

Advertisement

As background, Revenue NSW had originally assessed Godolphin for land tax for the 2014 to 2019 tax years in respect of its two properties (Kelvinside and Woodlands) in the Hunter Valley, contending that although the dominant use of the properties was for the maintenance of animals, that use was not for the required statutory purpose of selling those animals, their natural increase or bodily produce.

The NSW Supreme Court agreed with Godolphin that it conducted an integrated stud operation (involving both breeding and raising thoroughbred horses) such that the dominant use of both properties was for the maintenance of animals for the purpose of selling their bodily produce or natural increase.

In the Court's view, the objectives of winning races and pursuit of stallion excellence were part of the overall objectives of increasing the value of Godolphin's stud operations (being nomination fees in particular and sale of the majority of Godolphin's progeny) and that the sales were sufficiently proximate - if that was a required element - to the maintenance of the animals on the properties.

More particularly, on this view there was no requirement for a dominant purpose of sale, so long as there was a purpose of sale associated with the maintenance of animals on the land. Evidence before the Court indicated that the combined breeding and racing model was unusual for the industry. The sum at issue was $1.438 million.

  1. COURT OF APPEAL DECISION

To the disappointment of many of us, Revenue NSW, on appeal, recently had this Godolphin decision overturned.

The Court of Appeal has held that rural land used for a business that combined the breeding and racing of thoroughbred horses was not entitled to the exemption for land used for primary production. In other words, they successfully argued that the dominant use of the land was not for the maintenance of animals for the purpose of selling them or their natural increase or bodily produce.

The appeal court argued that the text and structure of the exemption rules as a whole, and the relevant authorities, indicated that the concepts of “use” and “purpose” are connected and should not be considered separately. In their words “use of land cannot be mixed into a conglomerate “animal maintenance” to which a purpose of sale then adheres.”

The court was prepared to accept that maintenance of animals could be made up of integrated uses but those could still have separate purposes. However, it was considered that the maintenance of animals on the land was comprised of integrated uses of breeding and racing, and each was conducted for dual and complimentary purposes, expressed succinctly in the Darley business credo “breed to race, race to breed”. In short, it was held that Godolphin had failed to show that one of those purposes predominated over the other.

Maybe all is not lost for industry players that seek land tax exemption who have a similar business model to Godolphin as the industry giant has sought leave to appeal to the High Court. Using an old racing adage, the race is far from over! Carrazzo will continue to monitor this case closely and update the industry on all major developments.

The case illustrates the issues that can arise when primary production land is used under business models that involve interrelated activities or integration of business activities. As it stands today, the test for exemption for primary production land is an all-or-nothing-test and this case shows that the purpose for which land is used can be just as important as the land use itself.

  1. WHAT DO WE LEARN FROM THIS CASE
  • This area of land tax exemption needs to be carefully considered by advisors, especially when dealing with State revenue authorities wishing to crack down on so called “abused” privileges.

 

  • Breeders who race too many offspring can not only compromise potential land tax exemption, but also income tax and GST business/enterprise status.
  • A Business Plan should always be prepared that expressly state the dominant use of the land and on what basis that is determined.

Please do not hesitate to contact the writer if you wish for me to clarify or expand on any of the matters raised in this article.

PAUL CARRAZZO CA

CARRAZZO CONSULTING PTY LTD

801 Glenferrie Road, Hawthorn, VIC, 3122

TEL:   (03) 9982 1000

FAX:   (03) 9329 8355

MOB:  0417 549 347

E-mail: paul.carrazzo@carrazzo.com.au

Web: www.carrazzo.com.au

Advertisment
More Reading...
When in Doubt Back a Frankel!
The $200,000 Listed ATC Lord Mayor’s Cup (2000m ) at Rosehill on Saturday attracted a competitive field of 14 stayers, the bulk of them imports and when you strike an open race like that it’s often wise to follow this piece of advice – when in doubt back a Frankel!
Bright Future for El Roca 3YO
Owner-trainer-breeder Kylie Little believes she might have a promising stayer on her hands with Eagle Rock, who left maiden ranks with an emphatic performance in Saturday’s Matt Edwards-Lime Group Mile (1600m) at Te Rapa.
Stakes Potential for New Hello Youmzain Winner
Late-season black type is on the radar for Platinum Diamond after an impressive upset victory in Saturday’s Full Circle Appearance Medicine 2YO (1200m) at Wanganui.
First Winner for Palace Pier
Kingman’s Champion 3YO Miler Palace Pier(GB) was a one term shuttler to Australia for Darley in 2022 and that crop will race next season, but in the meantime he had his first Northern Hemisphere winner overnight at Haydock.
Kiwi Bred Campaldino Wins G3 for Darby
Promising New Zealand-bred stayer Campaldino passed his biggest test with flying colours at Eagle Farm on Saturday, stepping up to stakes company and adding the A$200,000 Gr.3 Living Turf Queen Elizabeth II Cup (2400m) to his winning sequence.
Ears Back Wins Listed Stakes at Wanganui
A two-race North Island campaign has ended on a career-defining high for Ears Back and her Rangiora trainer John Blackadder, who scored their first black-type win in Saturday’s Listed AGC Training Stakes (1600m) at Wanganui.
Hat-Trick for Trelawney Stud Blueblood Filly
Well-related Trelawney Stud filly Madiyya signed off her three-year-old season with a third straight win, this time over 1600m in the A$150,000 Rod Griffiths Handicap at Caulfield on Saturday.
Another Win for Smart Exceedance Filly
Apprentice Liam Kauri has continued a winning association with the Lance O’Sullivan and Andrew Scott stable by partnering their smart three-year-old Tristar to victory in the Ambient Group 3YO (1100m) at Te Rapa, his second victory aboard the filly from just two rides.
Three Straight Stakes Wins For Cool Aza Beel’s Cool Archie
With no two-year-old currently performing better in Queensland, the Chirs and Corey Munce trained Cool Archie continued his outstanding form, taking out the $1m Group 2 BRC Sires’ Produce Stakes (1400m), his third consecutive black type victory.
First Local Win As New Endeavour (IRE) Records Stakes Success
While it may have taken the Gai Waterhouse and Adrian Bott trained New Endeavour (IRE) a while to record his first Australian success, connections were rewarded for their patience as the 5yo dominated under Tim Clark to win the Group 3 BRC Lord Mayor’s Cup (1800m) at Eagle Farm.