Top analyst says Catchy ‘no chance’ in Caulfield Guineas

Tom Baddock - Wednesday October 4

Respected sectionals analyst Vince Accardi has serious doubts surrounding the prospects of second-favourite Catchy in the upcoming Group I Caulfield Guineas (1600m).

Advertisement
Catchy will be up against it in the Group I Caulfield Guineas according to Vince Accardi. Photo: Darryl Sherer

Despite tasting defeat against her own age and sex in the Thousand Guineas Prelude (1400m) last Sunday, the Hayes' and Dabernig stable have decided to run the Blue Diamond heroine against the boys in the $2 million Caulfield Guineas instead of taking on her own sex in the $500,000 Thousand Guineas on the same day.


Watch Catchy in the Thousand Guineas Prelude

Accardi from Dailysectionals.com.au is of the opinion the daughter of Fastnet Rock would only be making up the numbers in the three-year-old feature.

"She's got no chance," Accardi said.

"The $5.50 about the Caulfield Guineas is crazy. Realistically I think she should be in excess of $10.

"She doesn't have one thing in her favour, other than she'll have less weight than the males, and I'm not a weights man but that would be her only advantage if you were trying to find one.

"At the moment the profile of the horse, if we work on her very best and her last start, she ran right up to her best.

"Generally she is three lengths behind what the current males are doing – this is without the expectation that the males won't improve any further then where they are already.

"So what the challenge is, let's assume that Catchy, and the data isn't indicating this, improves two or three lengths – the others would have to go backwards in order for her to beat them or they would need to have very bad luck or extreme bias.

"Even taking all that into consideration, at this stage Catchy has to be questionable to tackle the males, even the distance – there's nothing in the data to suggest the distance is going to be advantageous, particularly if there is high pressure.

"The data is indicating that if it's a soft run race she has a better chance of performing well but she still has to leap frog those few lengths.

"Generally speaking when I look at the past five years of the Caulfield Guineas the majority of them are run with a fair level of pressure and this would have her very vulnerable."

Accardi was of the opinion that Catchy would be much better suited back against the fillies in the Thousand Guineas.

"Up against her own age and sex she'd be competitive for sure," he said.

"The fillies have the tendency to run with a lot less pressure through the first 600m to 800m and therefore she'll get an opportunity to relax and breathe and give her every chance of running out a mile (1600m).

"The $5.50 is more realistically her price if she was running in the Thousand Guineas. There's not much between them.

"If it was my horse I'd be saying: 'let's target the Thousand Guineas, what are we trying to achieve?"

Catchy is currently $5.50 second-favourite for the Caulfield Guineas with Bet365 behind Royal Symphony at $5.

Advertisment
More Reading...
So You Think 3YO Wins $100,000 Inglis Xtra Bonus
Good placement from the Gai Waterhouse and Adrian Bott stable for progressive three year-old So You Think gelding Aloysius, who cast off maiden status at Hawkesbury on Thursday in a race that featured a lucrative Inglis Xtra maiden bonus.
Juvenile Trial Watch – Rosehill
There were six heats for juveniles at Rosehill on Friday morning and the winners include unraced youngsters by Cool Aza Beel and I Am Invincible, plus a Farnan colt that tried his luck in Group races in the autumn and was far from disgraced.
Sires With Winners - Friday July 4
Here is the full list of 38 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
One to Watch – Hawkesbury
Super Seth has had three G1 winners in Australia this season and John O’Shea and Tom Charlton have trained two of them, so when they produce a lightly raced maiden winner by this exciting young sire we want to know more.
Third Winner for Peltzer
Twin Hills Stud’s young sire Peltzer added a third winner to his tally with a debut victory at Canberra on Friday for the well named gelding I Show Speed.
Breeding To Win – Crystal Ball – New Season 3YOs to Follow
Analysis of the G1 winning 3YO’s for this season has made us realise how many horses on this list took giant strides from two to three, so we are looking into the crystal ball to find some juveniles we believe could end next season as G1 performers if not G1 winners.
High-flying Pencarrow Stud offers well-bred mares in Online Breeding Stock Sale
The 2024-25 season has been one of the best ever for Pencarrow Stud, and some of the renowned bloodlines that have underpinned that success are now available for purchase in the 2025 National Online Breeding Stock Sale on Gavelhouse Plus.
Invincible 2YO Colt wins for Bennett Racing
The $150,000 VRC Next Gen Sprinters Series Final (1200m) for two year-olds at Flemington on Saturday drew a competitive field of progressive juveniles and the colt that stood out on type in the yard was the one that got the cash with I Am Invincible colt Jimmy Recard proving too good for race favourite Bacash.
Spring Potential for Darby Racing's Raging Force
Unplaced in the Group III ATC Breeders’ Plate last spring on debut, Raging Force came out of that race with an injury that required significant time on the sidelines, but since returning to full work his progress has been swift.
One to Watch – Ballarat
Synthetic track meetings at Ballarat can throw up some misleading form, but a debut winner from the Tony and Calvin McEvoy stable that started in the red and won by nine lengths is probably worth a closer look.