Best On Breeding

Mark Smith - Friday January 17

Placed behind subsequent Melbourne Cup heroine Empire Rose in the New Zealand Oaks, Eau D'Etoile (Sir Tristram) became that rarest of broodmares with three Group 1 winners and a Listed stakes-winner to her credit on the way to earning Broodmare Of The Year status and that should have been her crowning achievement.

But she became the centre of a storm that had the potential to shape the thoroughbred breeding industry.Eau D'Etoile in happy retirement at Tyreel Stud. She died in 2008 - image Mark Smith

As the result of a difficulty pregnancy, Eau D'Etoile had a history of slipping. She went through two successful embryo transfers, where the embryo was put into a surrogate mare. Those foals were refused entry into the Stud Book and owner Jim Fleming signalled a legal battle.

While that failed to eventuate, Eau D'Etoile’s legacy continues to grow.

Her daughter Bint Marscay won the STC Golden Slipper, while her son Filante won the AJC Epsom Handicap and Kenny’s Best Pal won the VRC Australian Guineas. Her first foal Temple Fire produced the Group 1 winner Stella Cadente who is forming a successful branch of her own.

At the recent Magic Millions Gold Coast Yearling Sale, Stella Cadente’s stakes-placed daughter Starfish had a magnificent American Pharoah (USA) filly in the Coolmore draft that was sold for $575,000.

 Bint Marscay, along with her Group 1 winning daughter Bollinger (Dehere) and Group III winner Mannington (Danehill) all spent time at stud in the United States.

Mannington was sold for a record $2.05 million to Darley Stud at the 2005 William Inglis Australian Broodmare Sale.Exceed And Excel the sire of In Flanders - image Mark Smith

Before she left for the States, Mannington produced the Victoria Derby hero Benicio and the Group II Moonee Valley Fillies Classic winner Romneya.

Advertisement

In Kentucky, Mannington had a Kingmambo filly named Rose Trail who failed to race but has two European Stakes winners by Pivotal in the French Group III winner Rose Imperial and the dual Listed stakes-winner Rosental.

Romneya’s first foal Matilija (Medaglia d’Oro) was quick off the blocks winning two races at Moonee Valley before a pair of thirds in the Group III Typhoon Stakes at Moonee Valley and the Group III PJ Bell Stakes at Randwick.

Matilija’s first foal, the Exceed And Excel filly In Flanders, makes her second career start in the Iron Jack Hcp (1100m) to open proceedings at Rosehill on Saturday.

The Godolphin homebred has not started since finishing a meritorious fifth in the Group III ATC Gimcrack Stakes at Randwick back on October 5 last year.

She had little luck that day in what looks a strong edition of the race with Every Rose defeating last weeks $2 million Magic Millions 2yo Classic runner-up Stellar Pauline.

Advertisment
More Reading...
Exceed and Excel Colts Surge Late
The session topper for the first day of Magic Millions on Wednesday arrived late in proceedings with an Exceed and Excel colt from intriguing Frankel mare Dream in Colour (GB) selling for $1.1million to the bid of Coolmore’s Tom Magnier.
$3.3million Gun Runner Colt Tops Keeneland September Day 1
Keeneland’s 2025 September Yearling Sale began Monday with double-digit gains while posting a record average price of $653,208 and selling 15 horses for $1 million or more led by a colt by Gun Runner for $3.3 million to M.V. Magnier and Peter Brant’s White Birch Farm. The average topped the previous record $611,038 for a single session set during Day 2 in 2024, and the number of seven-
15th G1 Winner for Exceed and Excel
Turning 20 this year, Darley’s champion sire Exceed and Excel has just finished a super successful Magic Millions Sale that saw him with 24 yearlings average $398,542 to be the third leading sire by average and in South Africa on Saturday he posted a 15th Group I winner.
Waller Army Leads Cox Plate First Acceptances
Defending champion Via Sistina is among 21 horses champion trainer Chris Waller still has in contention for the $6 million 2025 Ladbrokes Cox Plate, following the closure of first acceptances on Tuesday.
G1 Manikato Next for Alabama Lass
New Zealand sprinter Alabama Lass will press on for a tilt at the Gr.1 Manikato Stakes (1200m) at The Valley later this month following her runner-up effort in the Gr.1 Moir Stakes (1000m) at the Melbourne track last Saturday.
Tragic News from Milburn Creek – Vale, Secret Admirer
Spring brings so many foaling stories from our studs each year and while the majority have a happy ending, sometimes things sadly don’t go as planned.
MRC Committee Returned Unopposed
The Melbourne Racing Club (MRC) has confirmed the results of the 2025 nominations for the MRC Executive Committee and the Mornington Advisory Group (MAG), which will be formally ratified at the Club’s Annual General Meeting on 25 September.
Kiwi Cup Hopeful Headed to Melbourne
Gr.1 Melbourne Cup (3200m) hopeful Wolfgang will fly to Melbourne on Wednesday to commence his path towards the A$10 million feature.
A New Benchmark for Edinburgh Stud
An emotional Ian Smith watched on as bidding reached $1 million for Edinburgh Stud’s stunning Exceed And Excel colt out of the Smoke Glacken mare Smokin’ Alice (USA) to set a new benchmark for the stud.
Exceed And Excel's Athelric Rewarded for Consistency
It was a 1-3 for Godolphin in Saturday’s Listed Queensland Day Stakes (1200m) for three-year-olds at Eagle Farm.