Stewards give their reasoning for no protests in the Muswellbrook horror show

Clinton Payne - Wednesday August 23

Racing NSW stewards say the video footage and final margins were the catalyst to no protests being lodged in an action-packed race at Muswellbrook on Tuesday where the $1.28 favourite Floki was beaten after suffering severe interference in the straight.

Advertisement

The Ben Smith-trained galloper was checked at least three times down the running before finishing third, beaten 2-1/2 lengths by Oakfield Time.

"Josh Adams reviewed the film with Floki's trainer Mr Smith and elected not to lodge an objection," Shane Cullen chief steward of the Hunter & North West racing association said.

"After they left the room we discussed amongst ourselves whether we thought there were grounds for the stewards to lodge an objection.

"We felt that given the rider and the trainer of the affected horse had view the footage, processed their thoughts and elected not to go ahead with an objection, we being of a similar view decided not to upset the conduct of the day by lodging an objection that we had no intention of upholding."

Floki was held up for a run when behind the leader Oakfield Time entering the straight before Floki's jockey Josh Adams attempted to force a passage between the leader and Final Frontier passing the 300m mark.

"Josh Adams attempted to improve between Oakfield Time and Final Frontier. What's important to note is that Josh Adams does it from a position behind Final Frontier," Cullen said.

"Josh Adams said in his evidence that he was trying to force that run.

"When he's doing that, Paul King (Final Frontier) from a position of a neck or a half-length forward of Josh Adams notices that Josh Adams is attempting that and manoeuvres his horse in to close that potential run.

"There was a run, a horse's width between Final Frontier and Oakfield Time when Oakfield Time shifts inwards as Paul King is attempting to keep Floki in behind that runner.

"Paul King does that in a manner that we say was within the boundaries that we've set.

"We don't want Paul King to leave a saloon passage for the odds-on favourite, Paul King has to do the very best he can on his own mount and if that includes and closing a possible run for any other runner, that's what he's obliged to do."

Stewards took no further action against King over the incident.

From there Adams angled Floki back to the inside of Oakfield Time, attempting a rails run inside the final 150m when Serg Lisnyy, the rider aboard Oakfield Time allowed his mount to shift in, causing Floki to hit the inside running rail as he was being checked.

"It's evident that near the 130m there is clearly a run for Floki," Cullen said. "This time Floki establishes that run.

"Oakfield Time was shifting around and shortly after Floki had improved to Oakfield Time's hind-quarter when the leader shifted in under riding.

"Serg Lisnyy shifted somewhere in the vicinity of three-quarters of a horse to a horse under riding and took away the run that Floki had established.

"Regarding a possible protest we had to consider would Floki had won if he's been able to keep that run. There was a reluctance by Floki to improve through that run because it was tight and we couldn't be comfortably satisfied that Floki would have finished ahead of Oakfield Time, as was Josh Adams or the trainer."

Lisnyy pleaded not guilty to a careless riding charge from the incident before stewards found him guilty and he was given a five meeting penalty, which was reduced from seven meetings as Floki's "greenness" was deemed to have contributed to the incident.

Advertisment
More Reading...
Steve Davis Awarded NZTBA Personality of the Year
Bloodstock auctioneer and media personality Steve Davis has been honoured as the 2025 NZTBA Personality of the Year, in recognition of a lifetime of contribution to the New Zealand thoroughbred breeding industry.
New G1 Winner for Too Darn Hot
Fresh from siring two new stakes-winners in Europe on Saturday Too Darn Hot (GB) kept the momentum going on Sunday with a new Group I winner and Tornado Alert is a half-brother to Just Fine (IRE), winner of the Group I ATC The Metropolitan in 2023.
Savabeel Stakes-Winner in the Making
A patient approach with Force Of Nature is being rewarded in spades, with the son of Savabeel winning his way toward black-type assignments.
Zousain Sunday 2YO Double
Zousain is surging to the end of the season with a double of new 2YO winners on Sunday bringing his seasonal tally of juvenile winners to 13.
Juvenile Trial Watch – Rosehill
This will be the last Juvenile Trial Watch story for this season with all these youngsters to turn three on Friday and there was plenty of action with eight heats won by 2YOs and two more of this season’s G3 2YO’s North England and Memo stepping out against the older G1 stars.
Carrazzo Melbourne 'Sport of Kings' Tax Talk
It gives Baumgartners great pleasure to announce that the Paul Carrazzo’s “Sport of Kings” horse tax talk returns to Inglis Melbourne on Wednesday 13 August.
Tenth Winner for Kings Legacy
King’s Legacy has had a promising start to his stud career with his tenth winner arriving on Tuesday while at the Rosehill trials one of his unraced youngsters produced a slick trial win to hold out Group performing colts Skyhook and West of Swindon.
Sires With Winners - Sunday July 27
Here is the full list of 54 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Fifth Winner For Hanseatic As Audio Pop Cam Wins
With four jumpouts under her belt, winning the last three, Tony and Calvin McEvoy's Hanseatic filly Audio Pop Cam was too good for her rivals, starting favourite to win the Unox Casa Maiden Plate (1100m) at Pakenham with ease.
Closer Look at Written Tycoon – The Golden Crop Delivers
The sun might be setting on the stud career of Written Tycoon, but he’s not going into the twilight years quietly and is set to be crowned Champion Australian 3YO Sire this season, which is probably something predicted by many when he got the opportunity of a lifetime to cover at Arrowfield Stud for one season in 2020.