What Could Have Been

Tara Madgwick - Monday June 25
The last Group I race of the Australian season, the Group I Tatts Tiara delivered victory for top class mare Prompt Response and got us thinking about her sire Beneteau and just what could have been had he not died after producing just two crops of foals at Arrowfield Stud.

BeneteauArrowfield have always had the policy of supporting good looking talented sons of their champion sires and Beneteau fit that profile when he retired to stud in 2011.

By champion sire Redoute's Choice, Beneteau was bred by Arrowfield and partners and made $1million when offered at the Inglis Australian Easter Yearling Sale and bought by Blue Sky Bloodstock.

He started just six times as a two year-old winning his first two starts before finishing third in the Group I MRC Blue Diamond Stakes and then returned to Sydney to be fifth in the Golden Slipper and sixth in the Champagne Stakes.

He was a good horse, but by no means a great one, so was priced at $11,000 and given the chance to make his own luck at stud.

His two crops of 131 foals, now four and five year-olds have produced 105 runners with 73 winners, 10 of which are stakes-winners headed by his Group I winners Prompt Response (image Steve Hart) and Lasqueti Spirit plus a further four Group winners.

Prompt ResponseThat's 9.5% stakes-winners to runners which marks him as a seriously good sire.

The results achieved by a horse like Beneteau go a long way to explaining why horses like Scissor Kick, Panzer Division and this year Pariah are given their chance at Arrowfield.

The lack of a Group I win on the resume does hold back the service fee charged for a sire, but in no way holds back their chance of success, just look at horses like I Am Invincible and Written Tycoon, two of the most commercial sires in the country.

When evaluating the merits of first season sires it's always good to look past the obvious Group I victories and take into consideration type and pedigree, look hard at what is standing in front of you rather than a race record which can sometimes be misleading.


Advertisment
More Reading...
Too Darn Hot Filly Chasing Guineas Start
Stablemates Oratia Beauty and Geneva will have opportunities to book their passages south when they step out at Ellerslie on Saturday.
800k Night of Thunder Colt Stars - Record-Breaking Tattersalls October Book 2 Concludes
Book 2 of the Tattersalls October Yearling Sale concluded with new benchmarks set for turnover and median. The sale aggregate of 70,124,500 guineas was well clear of the wide-margin record set in 2024, and the median of 76,000 guineas was a 9% increase on the previous year’s record equalling figure. The sale clearance rate was an excellent 92%.
Brave Smashing Out Winners
Yarraman Park’s Brave Smash (Jpn) has been on a winning roll since the start of this month and racked up his fifth winner for October when talented colt Smashing Lad scored an impressive maiden win at Warrnambool on Thursday.
Not This Time 2026 Fee Surges to US$250,000
When Widden Stud announced they would be shuttling Group I winning sprinter Cogburn (USA) to Australia this spring there were many Australian breeders who had to start doing some homework on his sire Not This Time.
Long Shot Oaks Winner Retired
Trainer Lee Curtis has announced the retirement of his former star filly Lasqueti Spirit, who will always be remembered for her unforgettable VRC Oaks win in 2016 as a $101 chance.
Sires With Winners - Wednesday October 15
Here is the full list of 42 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Best On Breeding
Saturday’s $700,000 Group 1 Kingsford Smith Cup (1300m) may be devoid of the sprinting big guns it shapes as a most competitive race.
Mr Mozart First Foals Impress at Highview Stud
Young Snitzel stallion Sword of State kicked off his stud career in the best way possible on Wednesday with an Aussie 2YO stakes-winner in Torture, but he’s not the only well credentialed son of Snitzel in New Zealand with Highview Stud home to Mr Mozart.
State of Excitement for Cambridge Stud
In a week where Cambridge Stud’s focus is largely around Joliestar’s tilt at the A$20 million Gr.1 The Everest (1200m), it was their first-season sire Sword Of State who was making headlines across the Tasman on Wednesday.
More Success for Newgate Raised Prompt Response
The Group II ATC Breeders Classic at Warwick Farm on Saturday was won by quality Beneteau mare Prompt Response, who was foaled and raised at Newgate Farm for her owner breeders Ron Hamer and Mark Sowerby.