Black Type Debacle Rears Head Again

Tara Madgwick - Sunday May 11

Should Know Thyself be a new stakes-winner for The Autumn Sun? Paul Messara thought he was after winning the ‘as advertised’ Listed $500,000 The Coast at Gosford on Saturday, but as it turns out he’s not.

Know Thyself - should he be a stakes-winner? - image Bradley Photography

After the race Paul Messara was obviously in the dark on the status of The Coast believing the win had credited The Autumn Sun with a new stakes-winner.

"It's a fantastic program coming through that Country Championships race," Messara said.

"There is plenty of races for him and it's hard to avoid these races, it's a Listed race and another stakes winner for The Autumn Sun, who we have up at stud.

"It's fantastic."

Does the race deserve to carry Black Type and is Know Thyself worthy of being a stakes-winner?

The answer on both counts would appear to be yes based on form and facts, but the race is one of the contentious set of races that were upgraded by Racing NSW at the start of the season without the authority of various international bodies that govern such things.

Advertisement

Know Thyself has won seven of 10 starts making a steady progression from country grades to metro racing and winning the $1million Country Championship Final before then taking out a Benchmark 78 event under 61 kg.

He is the very definition of a horse that has worked it’s way up to a level that is deserving of stakes recognition in a catalogue.

The horses he beat on Saturday are last start Group II BRC Queensland Guineas winner Depth of Character and Mare of Mt Buller, a last start winner of the Group III ATC Epona Stakes.

It defies all commonsense and logic that the current situation as regards Black Type racing in this country has not been resolved.

We’re not dealing with Ukraine or the Ghaza strip, it’s just a couple of races being upgraded and far more being downgraded to fit with the modern racing world in which we now live.

For whatever reason certain parties choose to make this a far more complex issue than it deserves to be, however allowing politics to get in the way of commonsense is something men are very good at.

Advertisment
More Reading...
DIY Pedigrees for Melbourne Cup – Take the Tip!
If you are having trouble settling on your Melbourne Cup horses a look at pedigree might be a help, so take a flick through our five generation pedigrees for all Cup runners and we’re giving you a clue as to what to look for!
2YOs on Show - Flemington Sale Mail
Cup Day at Flemingto will kick off with the Group III VRC Maribyrnong Plate (1000m) which has attracted a big field of juveniles including some unraced blueblood homebred babies for Godolphin and Yulong as well as the highest priced yearling by first crop sire Pinatubo (IRE).
Too Darn Hot’s Tornado Valley Captures G3 Maribyrnong Plate
With race experience on his side, having finished third on debut when beaten a length in the Listed MRC Debutant Stakes (1000m), the Ciaron Maher trained 2yo colt Toronado Valley (Too Darn Hot) kicked off Melbourne Cup day with victory in the $240,000 Group 3 VRC Darley Maribyrnong Plate (1200m).
Tara Talks Racing - Melbourne Cup Tips
If you are a racing tragic and horse lover like Clocker and I, Melbourne Cup Eve is as good as it gets, so have a listen to our thoughts and you can put the pen through our very dodgy tips or add them to your multiples!
A Century of National Yearling Sales Success: Melbourne Cup
There are many great events and coveted prizes on the Australian racing calendar, but no others capture attention quite like the Melbourne Cup (3200m).
El Vencedor Back to Best
Cambridge trainer Stephen Marsh was a relieved man following El Vencedor’s return to winning form in the Gr.3 Elsdon Park Balmerino Stakes (2000m) at Ellerslie on Tuesday.
Ghaiyyath 3yo Different Gravy Dominates Listed TAB Trophy
With jockey Mark Zahra in sensational form so far during the Melbourne Cup carnival, it was the Henry Dwyer trained Ghaiyyath 3yo Different Gravy who gave the leading jockey his sixth win from just nine rides so far, charging from back in the field to win the Listed $200,000 VRC TAB Trophy (1800m) on Tuesday.
Yes Yes Yes 3YO on Track for G1 Guineas
Pam Gerard is a bundle of nerves as she gets ready to shoot for her second consecutive victory in next week’s Gr.1 Al Basti Equiworld Dubai New Zealand 2000 Guineas (1600m) at Riccarton.
Exceedance Mare Wins G3 HKJC Stakes
The Bjorn Baker stable were in the winner’s circle at Flemington on Derby Day with Caballus and were back again on Cup Day with talented Exceedance mare Dance to the Boom, who landed the Group III VRC HKJC Stakes (1400m).
Sires With Winners - Tuesday November 4
Here is the full list of 163 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.