Black Type Debacle Rears Head Again

Tara Madgwick - Sunday May 11

Should Know Thyself be a new stakes-winner for The Autumn Sun? Paul Messara thought he was after winning the ‘as advertised’ Listed $500,000 The Coast at Gosford on Saturday, but as it turns out he’s not.

Know Thyself - should he be a stakes-winner? - image Bradley Photography

After the race Paul Messara was obviously in the dark on the status of The Coast believing the win had credited The Autumn Sun with a new stakes-winner.

"It's a fantastic program coming through that Country Championships race," Messara said.

"There is plenty of races for him and it's hard to avoid these races, it's a Listed race and another stakes winner for The Autumn Sun, who we have up at stud.

"It's fantastic."

Does the race deserve to carry Black Type and is Know Thyself worthy of being a stakes-winner?

The answer on both counts would appear to be yes based on form and facts, but the race is one of the contentious set of races that were upgraded by Racing NSW at the start of the season without the authority of various international bodies that govern such things.

Advertisement

Know Thyself has won seven of 10 starts making a steady progression from country grades to metro racing and winning the $1million Country Championship Final before then taking out a Benchmark 78 event under 61 kg.

He is the very definition of a horse that has worked it’s way up to a level that is deserving of stakes recognition in a catalogue.

The horses he beat on Saturday are last start Group II BRC Queensland Guineas winner Depth of Character and Mare of Mt Buller, a last start winner of the Group III ATC Epona Stakes.

It defies all commonsense and logic that the current situation as regards Black Type racing in this country has not been resolved.

We’re not dealing with Ukraine or the Ghaza strip, it’s just a couple of races being upgraded and far more being downgraded to fit with the modern racing world in which we now live.

For whatever reason certain parties choose to make this a far more complex issue than it deserves to be, however allowing politics to get in the way of commonsense is something men are very good at.

Advertisment
More Reading...
Aussie 2YO SW for Tivaci
New Zealand-bred colt Matahga stamped himself as an exciting spring three-year-old prospect with a hard-fought victory in the A$120,000 Listed David Peacock Oaklands Plate (1400m) at Morphettville on Saturday.
Sires With Winners - Friday June 27
Here is the full list of 48 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Almanzor Stayer wins G3 Tattersalls Cup
It's been a long time since the  2022 Victoria Derby and some may have wondered whether the winner Manzoice was ever going to win again!
Promising 2YOs for Pike
Tony Pike found it difficult to split his juvenile charges the last time they took each other on and it’s the same story at Ruakaka.
Better Than Ready’s Metalart Wins Group 3 W J Healy Stakes
Improving off a third in the Listed Lightning Handicap at Eagle Farm recently, 4yo Better Than Ready gelding Metalart stepped up to 1200m to record his first black type success, winning the Group 3 W J Healy Stakes.
Vinery Stud Announce Adam White as Interim Manager
From the 1st of July, Vinery Stud is pleased to announce the appointment of Adam White as Interim General Manager, following the resignation of Peter Orton. A dedicated and long-standing member of the Vinery team, Adam brings a wealth of experience and an in-depth understanding of both the business and the industry to this pivotal role.
Sires With Winners - Saturday June 28
Here is the full list of 109 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Cambridge Stud to Sell Entire Draft at Karaka 2026
Leading thoroughbred nursery Cambridge Stud have committed their full support for NZB’s 2026 National Yearling Sales Series, with the announcement they will be selling 100% of their yearling stock at Karaka. 
Wootton Bassett Winning Whirl
It was a red letter day for Wootton Bassett (GB) at The Curragh overnight with a treble of winners highlighted by top class filly Whirl, who captured the Group I Pretty Polly Stakes (1m2f), a race won by the mighty Via Sistina in 2023.
Corumbene Stud Homebred Tashi Wins G1 Tatts Tiara
From the last crop of foals sired by Widden Stud’s much missed Golden Slipper winning sire Sebring, five year-old mare Tashi may also be his final Group I winner as she produced a career best performance at Eagle Farm on Saturday to win the $700,000 Group I Tatts Tiara (1400m).