Why the whip rules will never be black and white

Tom Walter - Wednesday October 11

The aftermath of last Saturday's Group I Spring Champion Stakes brought the controversial whip rule back into the spotlight so Racenet has sought clarification from Racing NSW chief steward Marc Van Gestel.

Advertisement

Ace High defeated Tangled in a thrilling finish to the Spring Champion Stakes (2000m) at Randwick before stewards identified that Ace High's rider Tye Angland had struck his mount nine times prior to the 100m mark – four more than the permitted amount.

Stewards ultimately concluded that Angland's infringement did not have a tangible effect on the result but fined the jockey $4000.

The margin between Ace High and Tangled on the line was a short head, which raises the question – how can we objectively quantify the influence whip use has had on a particular runner?

The simple answer is we can't, because horses respond to whip use in vastly different ways – some need it to keep their mind on the job while others don't need it at all.

The unfortunate reality is that the stewards' decision on a whip-related protest is purely discretionary which breeds controversy, especially when the stakes are high such as in last Saturday's $500,000 Spring Champion Stakes (to say nothing of the fact that both Ace High and Tangled are stud-aspiring colts).

"It is a subjective decision where we have to be satisfied that if a horse is struck illegally it has either responded or continued to sustain its effort as a result of those illegal strikes," Van Gestel said.

"With the Ace High incident, the stewards couldn't be satisfied that four extra strikes of the whip resulted in the winner gaining an unfair advantage.

"I think in a circumstance where you have a rider significantly breaching the rule, such as 15 successive strikes before the 100m, then stewards could be satisfied that an alteration of placings may be warranted."

Jockeys have long expressed their disapproval of the whip rules and shortly after the Spring Champion Stakes, Angland joined the chorus, tweeting: "A very hard rule to focus on while trying to do your best to win."

One can only imagine what it must be like to count whip strikes while nearing exhaustion on a 500kg animal.

But if the rule is indeed here to stay, jockeys will have to adapt as some instances of whip breaches will attract more than just a fine.

"Fines are not the only deterrent. Stewards also have the power to forfeit a winning jockey's percentage of prizemoney which can obviously be significant in feature races," Van Gestel said.

"And if we think there are grounds for objection then we will lodge one. Similarly, connections have the power to do it as well.

"At the moment we don't think there's a necessity to make any further announcements regarding the rule."

Considering what transpired at the weekend, is a protest on grounds of excessive whip use now inevitable?

Advertisment
More Reading...
McGaw Firms For Coolmore Stud Stakes After G2 Danehill Win
Considered an outside chance in betting markets, Emma-Lee and David Browne’s I Am Immortal gelding McGaw dented the reputation of a few leading Group 1 Coolmore Stud Stakes contenders with a fighting win in the $300,000 Gr2 VRC Danehill Stakes (1100m) at Flemington on Saturday.
Sires With Winners - Saturday October 4
Here is the full list of 119 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
War Machine Stakes Everest Claim - G2 Gilgai
David Hayes has a New Zealand-bred superstar heading into the A$20 million Gr.1 The Everest (1200m) in two weeks, where his sons Ben, Will and JD Hayes might line up against him with a Kiwi-bred Group One winner of their own.
G1 Metrop Win for Australian Bloodstock
Second in the Italian Derby at three, progressive stayer Royal Supremacy (IRE) had racked up multiple Group placings in Europe before his sale to Australian Bloodstock and broke through for his first ever stakes win when taking out the $750,000 Group I ATC The Metropolitan (2400m) at Randwick on Saturday.
Apocalyptic Crowned Darley Princess with G1 Flight Victory
Extreme Choice filly Apocalyptic has been the dominant force in the Darley Princess Series this year and she claimed the jewel in the crown at Randwick on Saturday with a commanding win in the $750,000 Group I ATC Flight Stakes (1600m).
Sensational Seven - Autumn Glow Remains Unbeaten With G1 Epsom Victory
Chasing her first Group 1 victory and in the process attempting to remain unbeaten, outstanding 4yo mare Autumn Glow did all that and more, jumping from the outside barrier to give Chris Waller his sixth victory in the $1.5m Group 1 ATC Epsom Handicap (1600m) at Randwick on Saturday.
Miraval Rose Impresses With G2 Rose Of Kingston Stakes Win
Already a Listed winner at 3 and 4, Grahame Begg’s Grunt mare Miraval Rose added her third black type victory to her record, winning the $300,000 Group 2 VRC Rose Of Kingston Stakes (1400m) in style at Flemington on Saturday.
Sir Delius Delivers G1 Turnbull Stakes Win
Adding Saturday’s $750,000 Group 1 VRC Turnbull Stakes (2000m) to his Group 1 MRC Underwood Stakes (1800m) victory last start, the Gai Waterhouse and Adrian Bott trained Sir Delius further enhanced his outstanding reputation ahead of an assault on the WS Cox Plate and Melbourne Cup.
Pedigree Watch – Juvenile Stakes-Winners
Three new season juvenile stakes races on Saturday produced a $1million yearling purchase that gave Golden Slipper winner Stay Inside the perfect start to his stud career, a pinhook winner turned stakes-winner and a colt foaled in Australia with a Kiwi pedigree.
Briasa Wins $1million G2 Premiere Stakes- Everest Next
Twin Hills Stud’s Smart Missile will have a runner in the $20million The Everest and his explosive grey sprinter Briasa will be going into the race in top form following an exciting win at Randwick on Saturday in  the $1million Group I ATC Premiere Stakes (1200m).