Why the whip rules will never be black and white

Tom Walter - Wednesday October 11

The aftermath of last Saturday's Group I Spring Champion Stakes brought the controversial whip rule back into the spotlight so Racenet has sought clarification from Racing NSW chief steward Marc Van Gestel.

Advertisement

Ace High defeated Tangled in a thrilling finish to the Spring Champion Stakes (2000m) at Randwick before stewards identified that Ace High's rider Tye Angland had struck his mount nine times prior to the 100m mark – four more than the permitted amount.

Stewards ultimately concluded that Angland's infringement did not have a tangible effect on the result but fined the jockey $4000.

The margin between Ace High and Tangled on the line was a short head, which raises the question – how can we objectively quantify the influence whip use has had on a particular runner?

The simple answer is we can't, because horses respond to whip use in vastly different ways – some need it to keep their mind on the job while others don't need it at all.

The unfortunate reality is that the stewards' decision on a whip-related protest is purely discretionary which breeds controversy, especially when the stakes are high such as in last Saturday's $500,000 Spring Champion Stakes (to say nothing of the fact that both Ace High and Tangled are stud-aspiring colts).

"It is a subjective decision where we have to be satisfied that if a horse is struck illegally it has either responded or continued to sustain its effort as a result of those illegal strikes," Van Gestel said.

"With the Ace High incident, the stewards couldn't be satisfied that four extra strikes of the whip resulted in the winner gaining an unfair advantage.

"I think in a circumstance where you have a rider significantly breaching the rule, such as 15 successive strikes before the 100m, then stewards could be satisfied that an alteration of placings may be warranted."

Jockeys have long expressed their disapproval of the whip rules and shortly after the Spring Champion Stakes, Angland joined the chorus, tweeting: "A very hard rule to focus on while trying to do your best to win."

One can only imagine what it must be like to count whip strikes while nearing exhaustion on a 500kg animal.

But if the rule is indeed here to stay, jockeys will have to adapt as some instances of whip breaches will attract more than just a fine.

"Fines are not the only deterrent. Stewards also have the power to forfeit a winning jockey's percentage of prizemoney which can obviously be significant in feature races," Van Gestel said.

"And if we think there are grounds for objection then we will lodge one. Similarly, connections have the power to do it as well.

"At the moment we don't think there's a necessity to make any further announcements regarding the rule."

Considering what transpired at the weekend, is a protest on grounds of excessive whip use now inevitable?

Advertisment
More Reading...
Two New SW's for Too Darn Hot
Too Darn Hot is set to be crowned Champion Australian Second Season Sire and is headed back to Darley Australia this spring at a fee of $275,000 and overnight he produced two new stakes-winners in the UK and Ireland.
Consecutive Black Type Victories For Snitzel Filly Bridal Waltz
Stepping up to open company is always a tough task, but 3yo Snitzel filly Bridal Waltz graduated from a last start Listed win over her own age to win the $200,000 Group 3 MRC Bletchingly Stakes (1200m) at Caulfield.
Season Finale Flourish for So You Think
Coolmore stalwart So You Think is powering to the end of the Australian racing season with a six winner flurry on Saturday highlighted by a winning treble at Randwick led by his progressive mare Oh Diamond Lil.
Winning Hat-Trick for Gold Standard 2YO
When an unheralded sire produces a Group I winner in their first crop as happened for Sebring stallion Gold Standard it can take a long time for the benefit of that early splash to take effect, but in his case the wait is nearly over and in the meantime Destiny’s Summit is a good reminder as to his merit.
Another G1 Triumph for Aga Khan Stud Bred Gelding
Aga Khan Studs don’t race a lot of geldings, but one that they do is Calandagan, who made it back to back G1 wins overnight when beating a select field in a tactical battle to win the Group I King George VI and Queen Elizabeth Stakes (1m4f) at Ascot.
Unbeaten Run Continues For Ole Kirk’s Daughter Ole Dancer
Successful in the Magic Millions SA 2YO Classic at Murray Bridge on debut back in March, the Peter Moody and Katherine Colemen trained filly Ole Dancer resumed at Sandown on Saturday, winning the Senet Gambling Law Experts Handicap (1200m) to remain unbeaten.
One to Watch Wins Again in Saturday Class
The half-brother to Group II winner Stretan Angel, lightly raced three year-old Brutal gelding Glorious Moments was in a class of his own at Randwick on Saturday.
Hello Youmzain Filly Wins NZ Last Stakes Race of Season
Talented juvenile filly Platinum Diamond made all posts a winner when she captured her second consecutive stakes victory in the last black type feature of the 2024-2025 racing season, the Listed Phils Electrical & Gypsy Caravans Ryder Stakes (1200m) at Otaki.
Sires With Winners - Saturday July 26
Here is the full list of 86 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
First SW For So You Think Stallion Tamasa As Cicala Takes Out Lightning
One of just three named foals by the So You Think stallion Tamasa, the Will Clarken and Niki O’Shea trained 3yo filly Cicala remained unbeaten, going three from three by winning the $120,000 Listed SAJC Lightning Stakes (1050m) at Morphettville.